A couple of years at the NCTA (The Cable Show) I spent some time in the TiVo booth, talking with representatives of the company on how they were moving their product forward. At the time, I was struck by the elegance of their on-screen GUI, the intuitiveness of their remote, and in general, the direction the company seemed to be heading. Like the SA/Cisco DVR, a TiVo box is not a server in the classic sense of a DLNA based system, (more of a client really), but, like AppleTV, can function as a server for a single video system. TiVo has enough uniqueness that I feel it bears some discussion here.
TiVo is representative of an increasing trend where video consumers purchase hardware that allows access to a number of digital video and music sources; i.e., cable, Netflix, YouTube, Amazon, etc. TiVo can function as a classic DVR, with the full feature set associated with that device. But in addition, all of the new TiVo products are internet savvy, which allows access to popular digital sources available on the internet as well.
One of the most controversial aspects of TiVo is the monthly subscription fee, which, unlike cable video services or Netflix, does not buy access to any content. It only buys access to the programming guide which is tightly integrated into the DVR system. Cost per month varies from about $12.95 to a little under $7.00, depending on how long a contract is chosen. Without the service contract, according to TiVo, the box “will have very limited functions…the only thing you would be able to do is record live TV.” Basically a paperweight…
While as mentioned before, the box (currently the Premiere® or the Premiere XL®) is well designed generally, there are a few goofy things that should have been anticipated by the company. For example, it lacks a built-in 802.11n network access point, and, if you want the internet enabled features over wireless, you must plunk down another $90 for the external adapter (another wired goober to hide somewhere). If you have wired ethernet near your video set up, no problem. But this is a design flaw that the company should have anticipated with its new set top design.
Most of the folks I have talked to that have the TiVo service think it’s great–it enhances the experience from cable, Netflix, and other video services. The TiVo system does have a 30-day money back guarantee.
As we have covered some of the new generation HD sets available, it appears that many of them are incorporating internet savvy applications to access video content from a number of sources. I’m anxious for the day when it will be possible to interface an external hard disk to the TV, and DVR functionality would then be part of the set’s interface. That may not be that far off.
In the meantime, TiVo is a viable option out there to increase access to and usability of digital content in a sophisticated home theatre set up. Whether it’s precisely the best alternative for you (as a video server or client) depends on your needs and tastes.
Until next time….




